Mathematics Problem Archive
Problem 5.8 — (Sharp bounds for involution generating sets).
v1.3 research notes(Sharp bounds for involution generating sets). For each g≥ 2, prove sharp bounds for the minimal number of involutions required to generate Modg. In p...
Problem 5.9 — (Cohomological Dimension).
v1.3 research notes(Cohomological Dimension). Compute the cohomological dimension of Ig and ofKg. More generally, compute the cohomological dimension of Ig(k) for all k≥...
Problem 5.11 — (Torelli finiteness).
v1.3 research notes(Torelli finiteness). Determine the maximal number f (g) for which there is a K(Ig, 1) space with finitely many cells in dimensions ≤f (g). Here is wh...
Conjecture 5.12 — Ig is finitely presented for g≥ 4.
v1.3 research notesIg is finitely presented for g≥ 4. One thing we do know is that, in contrast to Mod g, neither Ig norKg has a classifying space which is homotopy equi...
Problem 5.14 — Extend Akita’s result to 2<g < 7.
v1.3 research notesExtend Akita’s result to 2<g < 7. Since Akita’s proof produces no explicit homology classes, the following seems fundamental....
Problem 5.15 — (Explicit cycles).
v1.3 research notes(Explicit cycles). Explicitly construct infinitely many linearly independent cy- cles in H∗(Ig, Q) and H∗(Kg, Q). So, we are still at the stage of try...
Problem 5.16 — Determine the subalgebras of H ∗(Ig,K ), for K = Q and K = F2, generated by H 1(Ig,K ).
v1.3 research notesDetermine the subalgebras of H ∗(Ig,K ), for K = Q and K = F2, generated by H 1(Ig,K ). Note that H ∗(Ig,K ) is a module over Sp(2 g,K ). When K = Q t...
Question 5.18 — For which k≥ 1 is it true that Aut(Ig(k)) = Mod ± g?
v1.3 research notesFor which k≥ 1 is it true that Aut(Ig(k)) = Mod ± g? that Comm(Ig(k)) = Mod± g? Theorem 5.17 answers the question for k = 1, 2. It would be remarkable...
Problem 5.19 — Give an elementary, purely combinatorial-topological and group-theoretic, proof of Hain ’s theorem.
v1.3 research notesGive an elementary, purely combinatorial-topological and group-theoretic, proof of Hain ’s theorem. It seems that a solution to Problem 5.19 will like...
Problem 5.20 — (Hain for Aut( Fn)).
v1.3 research notes(Hain for Aut( Fn)). Give an explicit finite presentation for the Malcev Lie AlgebraL(IAn), where IAn is the group of automorphisms of the free group ...
Problem 5.21 — (Malcev mod 2).
v1.3 research notes(Malcev mod 2). Give an explicit finite presentation for the F2-Lie algebra L2(Ig,1). We can also build a Lie algebra using the Johnson filtration. Le...
Question 5.22 — (Lie algebra for the Johnson filtration).
v1.3 research notes(Lie algebra for the Johnson filtration). Is hg a finitely presented Lie algebra? If so, give an explicit finite presentation for it....
Problem 5.23 — Compute H1(Modg[L]; Z).
v1.3 research notesCompute H1(Modg[L]; Z). McCarthy and (independently) Hain proved that H1(Modg[L], Z) is finite for g≥ 3; see, e.g. Proposition 5.2 of [ Ha2]7. As disc...
Conjecture 5.24 — (Picard number one conjecture for level L structures).
v1.3 research notes(Picard number one conjecture for level L structures). Prove that H2(Modg[L]; Q) = Q when g≥ 3. More generally, compute H2(Modg[L]; Z) for all g≥ 3,L≥...
Problem 5.25 — (Presentation for level L structures).
v1.3 research notes(Presentation for level L structures). Give an explicit finite presentation for Modg[L]. Once one has such a presentation, it seems likely that it wou...
Problem 6.1 — (Actions on buildings).
v1.3 research notes(Actions on buildings). Determine all isometric actions ψ: Mod g→ Isom(Xn), whereXn is an n-dimensional Euclidean building, and n is sufficiently small ...
Question 6.2 — (Rigidity of the Mod g,1 action on S1).
v1.3 research notes(Rigidity of the Mod g,1 action on S1). Is any faithful action ρ: Mod g,1→ Homeo+(S1) conjugate in Homeo+(S1) to the standard action, given in (19)? W...
Question 6.3 — (orderability).
v1.3 research notes(orderability). Does Modg,g ≥ 2 have some finite index subgroup which acts faithfully by homeomorphisms on S1? Does either Modg or Modg,1 have a finit...
Question 6.4 — ((Non)residual finiteness).
v1.3 research notes((Non)residual finiteness). Is the (universal) central extension ˜Modg,1 of Modg,1 residually finite, or not? Note that an old result of Grossman stat...
Problem 6.5 — (The sections problem).
v1.3 research notes(The sections problem). Determine those subgroups H ≤ Modg for which π has a section over H. Do this as well with Homeo+(Σg) replaced by various subgr...
Question 6.6 — (Sections over finite index subgroups).
v1.3 research notes(Sections over finite index subgroups). Does the natural map Homeo+(Σg)→ Modg have a section over a finite index subgroup of Modg, or not? Of course t...
Question 6.7 — Does Modg or any of its finite index subgroups have any faithful action by homeomorphisms on Σg?
v1.3 research notesDoes Modg or any of its finite index subgroups have any faithful action by homeomorphisms on Σg?...
Question 7.1 — Does limg→∞gL(Modg) exist?
v1.3 research notesDoes limg→∞gL(Modg) exist? Another basic open question is the following....
Question 7.2 — Is the sequence {L(Modg)} monotone decreasing?
v1.3 research notesIs the sequence {L(Modg)} monotone decreasing? strictly so? Explicit values of L(Modg) are known only when g = 1. In this case one is simply asking fo...
Problem 7.3 — Compute L(Modg) explicitly for small g≥ 2.
v1.3 research notesCompute L(Modg) explicitly for small g≥ 2. In principle L(Modg) can be computed for any given g. The point is that one can first bound the degree of L...
Question 7.4 — Is there a unique (up to conjugacy) minimal dilation pseudo-Anosov in Modg?
v1.3 research notesIs there a unique (up to conjugacy) minimal dilation pseudo-Anosov in Modg? Note that this is true for g = 1; the unique minimum is realized by the co...
Problem 7.5 — (Shortest Teichm¨ uller loop in a stratum).
v1.3 research notes(Shortest Teichm¨ uller loop in a stratum). For each fixed g≥ 2, and for each r-tuple as above, give upper and lower bounds for λg(k1,...,k r):= inf {...
Question 7.6 — Does spec(Ig(k)) have bounded multiplicity for k≥ 3?
v1.3 research notesDoes spec(Ig(k)) have bounded multiplicity for k≥ 3? One way to get around unbounded multiplicities is to look at the simple length spectrum, which is...
Question 7.7 — (Simple length spectrum).
v1.3 research notes(Simple length spectrum). Does the simple length spectrum of Mg, endowed with the Teichm¨ uller metric, have bounded multiplicity? If so, how does the...
Problem 7.8 — Give an algorithm which tells whether or not any given pseudo-Anosov is represented by a simple closed Teichm¨ uller…
v1.3 research notesGive an algorithm which tells whether or not any given pseudo-Anosov is represented by a simple closed Teichm¨ uller geodesic, and also whether or not...
Question 7.11 — Give upper and lower bounds for L(Ig(k)) for all k≥ 2 which are of the same order of magnitude.
v1.3 research notesGive upper and lower bounds for L(Ig(k)) for all k≥ 2 which are of the same order of magnitude. In [ FLM] bounds on L(H) are given for various special...
Question 7.12 — For various subgroups H <Modg, compute the density of spec(H) in spec(Modg) and the density of H∩Pg inPg.
v1.3 research notesFor various subgroups H <Modg, compute the density of spec(H) in spec(Modg) and the density of H∩Pg inPg. In particular, what is the density of spec(M...
Problem 4.1 — ( Topological Schottky Problem).
v1.3 research notes( Topological Schottky Problem). Understand the homotopy type of Jc g and use it to compute H •(Jc g ) and H • c (Jc g ). The first interesting case i...
Problem 4.2 — Determine whether or not H•(Tg; Z[1/2])− is always a finitely generated Z[1/2]- module.
v1.3 research notesDetermine whether or not H•(Tg; Z[1/2])− is always a finitely generated Z[1/2]- module. Does the infinite topology of Tg comes from Jg? To get one’s h...
Problem 4.3 — Determine good bounds for the homological dimension (or the CW-dimension) ofT c g.
v1.3 research notesDetermine good bounds for the homological dimension (or the CW-dimension) ofT c g....
Problem 4.5 — Try to understand the “topology at infinity” of T c g.
v1.3 research notesTry to understand the “topology at infinity” of T c g. In particular, try to compute Hk ∞(T c g ) for k in some range k≥do. Alternatively, try to comp...
Problem 4.6 — Compute H • ∞(T c 3 ).
v1.3 research notesCompute H • ∞(T c 3 ). The homology of T c g is related to that of Tg via the Gysin sequence. In order to apply it, one needs to understand the topolo...
Problem 4.7 — Compute the Spg(Z)-moduleHk c (T c,red g ) in some range k≥ko.
v1.3 research notesCompute the Spg(Z)-moduleHk c (T c,red g ) in some range k≥ko. 3. Finiteness and Torelli spaces 71 We already know that H 6g−7 c (T c,red g ) = H0(Bc ...
Conjecture 4.8 — Each component of Hc g is simply connected.
v1.3 research notesEach component of Hc g is simply connected. This is trivially true in genus 2, where there is one component which is all of h2. If true in genus 3, it...
Problem 4.9 — Investigate the topology of Hg andHc g and their components.
v1.3 research notesInvestigate the topology of Hg andHc g and their components. Specifically, compute their homology and the cohomology at infinity of Hc g,α. The period...
Conjecture — Every subgroup of finite index in ModS contains a congruence subgroup.
v1.3 research notesEvery subgroup of finite index in ModS contains a congruence subgroup. V. Voevodsky had indicated (in a personal communication) a beautiful applicatio...
Question I — s it true that any normal subgroup is commensurable with such a subgroup?
v1.3 research notess it true that any normal subgroup is commensurable with such a subgroup? Recall that two subgroups Γ 1, Γ2 of a group G are commensurable if the inte...
Question I — s it possible that all nontrivial (i.e., ̸= 1 ) elements of a normal subgroup of ModS are pseudo-Anosov?
v1.3 research notess it possible that all nontrivial (i.e., ̸= 1 ) elements of a normal subgroup of ModS are pseudo-Anosov? To the best of my knowledge, this question wa...
Conjecture I — f Γ is an irreducible arithmetic group of rank ≥ 2, then every homomorphism Γ→ ModS has finite image.
v1.3 research notesf Γ is an irreducible arithmetic group of rank ≥ 2, then every homomorphism Γ→ ModS has finite image. For many arithmetic groups Γ the conjecture can ...
Question I — s there a constant NS, depending only on S, such that the following holds?
v1.3 research notess there a constant NS, depending only on S, such that the following holds? Let f∈ ModS and let t =t±1 α1◦t±1 α2◦···◦ t±1 αn is a Dehn multi-twist. If ...
Question I — s it true that H 1(Γ) = 0 for any subgroup Γ of finite index in ModS?
v1.3 research notess it true that H 1(Γ) = 0 for any subgroup Γ of finite index in ModS? It is well known that H 1(ModS) = 0. In his 1999 MSU Ph.D. thesis F. Taherkhani ...
Question — Does ModS has the Kazhdan property (T)?
v1.3 research notesDoes ModS has the Kazhdan property (T)? A positive answer would imply the positive answer to the previous question, but this problems seems to be much...
Question — What is the growth rate of dW (tn, 1)?
v1.3 research notesWhat is the growth rate of dW (tn, 1)? One would expect that either the growth is linear, or dW (tn, 1) = O(logn). In the arithmetic groups case, the ...
Conjecture I — f f is pseudo-Anosov element of a mapping class group ModS with sufficiently big dilatation coefficient, then the subgrou…
v1.3 research notesf f is pseudo-Anosov element of a mapping class group ModS with sufficiently big dilatation coefficient, then the subgroup of ModS normally generated by f...
Question — Are there any other relations between N -th powers Tγ = tN γ of Dehn twists for sufficiently high N?
v1.3 research notesAre there any other relations between N -th powers Tγ = tN γ of Dehn twists for sufficiently high N? In other words, do the above relations provide a pr...